Prime Professional Office Building
$1,250,000 - Commercial
Prime Professional Office Building in an ideal Cooperstown location. The Railroad Avenue district offers a boutique hotel, office and retail space, and a thriving distillery…
More Details Sort By:
Otsego Lake Classic Cottage
$950,000 - Country, Lake
Otsego Lake Classic Cottage – ±8 surveyed acres with ±205′ direct lake front on Otsego Lake at Hyde Bay. A mix of light woods, lawns,…
More Details132 Stocking Brook – Cooperstown Country Executive Estate
$849,000 - Country
This unique country home started life as a c.1887 barn in Sharon Springs, New York. Moved to its current ±18.72 acre Pierstown location and reconstructed…
More DetailsBy The Lake
$751,000 - Village
Located at the end of Cooperstown’s Pioneer Street, next to Pioneer Park, at the foot of Otsego Lake, this 1992Eyebrow Colonial has been lovingly updated…
More Detailsc1860 French Country Style Farmhouse
$749,000 - Village
The house has been beautifully and attentively maintained. This attractive residence sits on ±1.16 acres and provides ±3,179 SF of fine living space. As you…
More DetailsIncomparable Fly Creek Valley View Home
$749,000 - Country, Village
A rare opportunity to live just a few minutes from the Village of Cooperstown yet experience ±21-acres of seclusion and privacy on a quiet country…
More DetailsMt. Otsego
$742,500 - Country
Welcome to Mt. Otsego – This sprawling c1836 farmhouse sits at the foot of the former Mt. Otsego Ski Area, one of the first ski…
More DetailsEarly 1800’s charmer
$690,000 - Village
Looking like a Currier and Ives painting, this well-known early 1800’s charmer sits on 11+ acres on a quiet country road, just ten minutes from…
More DetailsThe Jewel of Pierstown
$610,000 - Country
Originally referred to as “The Jewel of Pierstown”, this wonderful Victorian is filled with nooks and crannies. Main floor offers the kitchen w/bay area, formal…
More DetailsCooperstown Greek Revival
$600,000 - Village
Charming c.1841 with 1910 addition, this Lake Street home offers ±2,656 square feet of gracious living space. Lovely large entry hall with open staircase, formal…
More DetailsSwanswick Barn
$500,000 - Country, Village
Swanswick Barn – the car collector’s dream – a 6,000 SF modern custom garage, designed by Hans deWaal, and built by Ralph J. Morely, Inc.…
More DetailsClassic Otsego Lake Cottage with ±60′ Direct Lakefront
$495,000 - Lake
Rilleroost – an idyllic waterfront cottage on Otsego Lake. This solidly constructed sun-kissed gem offers modern conveniences in a relaxing setting, with year-round potential. Offered…
More DetailsCooperstown Village Cottage
$479,000 - Village
Located in mid-Village within walking distance of Bassett Medical Center, Main Street, Clark Sports Center, and Otsego Lake, this very sweet c1855 ±1,600 square foot…
More DetailsMulti-Family Village Victorian
In Contract $459,000 - Village
194 Main Street – This 1885 Three Story, Three Family Victorian home is just one block from the Otesaga Hotel, two blocks from Otsego Lake…
More DetailsPrivate Sprawling Country Home
$375,000 - Country, Land
Nicely situated in the middle of its’ own 65+- private acres, this sprawling country home has been owned by the same family for many years. …
More DetailsTen minutes from Cooperstown,
$369,000 - Country
Just about ten minutes from Cooperstown, this very nicely built 1992 A-Frame sits on 14.31 acres on a private cul-de-sac in the Town of Middlefield.…
More Details1988 three bedroom, three bath home sits back off the road on ±1.8 acres
$345,000 - Commercial, Village
Welcome to this charming 1988 three bedroom, three bath home situated on ±1.8 acres of picturesque land. This property boasts a large yard with beautiful…
More DetailsCooperstown Country Cape
$345,000 - Country, Village
Just outside of Cooperstown on Beaver Meadow Road, this ±1,700 SF Cape Cod set on ±1 acre offers a private country setting with lawns, shade…
More Details125 Valenza Lane, Cooperstown, NY 13326
$329,000 - Country, Lake
Come build your sanctuary dream home and summer getaway on idyllic Otsego Lake. ±4.88 surveyed acres Otsego Lake parcel with ±43.76′ of private direct lake…
More DetailsUpgraded Country Home
$223,000 - Country
Just ±3.8 miles from the Village of Cooperstown, this ±1,609 square foot house sits on ±0.86 acres surrounded by perennial gardens, mature shade trees, and…
More DetailsCountry Saltbox on ±2.49 Acres
$145,000
This ±2,400 SF seasonal home sits on ±2.49 acres with a beautiful pond, and stream. Spacious open floor plan with living and dining areas offers…
More Details